1 00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:01,760 In the criminal justice system, 2 00:00:01,800 --> 00:00:05,680 the people are represented by two separate yet equally important groups... 3 00:00:05,720 --> 00:00:08,040 the police, who investigate crime, 4 00:00:08,080 --> 00:00:10,760 and the Crown Prosecutors, who prosecute the offenders. 5 00:00:10,800 --> 00:00:12,800 These are their stories. 6 00:00:13,960 --> 00:00:15,960 I could have left you. 7 00:00:17,680 --> 00:00:21,440 I could have... walked away... 8 00:00:24,200 --> 00:00:26,200 ..and you'd still be sick. 9 00:00:28,920 --> 00:00:30,920 But I didn't. 10 00:00:31,960 --> 00:00:33,960 Even though it was wrong. 11 00:00:39,280 --> 00:00:41,280 Because I want you. 12 00:00:42,880 --> 00:00:44,880 I don't care what the law says. 13 00:00:47,720 --> 00:00:49,920 I've always wanted you. 14 00:00:51,560 --> 00:00:55,160 Philip Gardner. Child psychiatrist. 50 years old. 15 00:00:55,200 --> 00:00:57,880 He's married. Two kids. Lives just round the corner. 16 00:00:57,920 --> 00:01:01,000 The cleaner found him this morning. She's downstairs, in tears. 17 00:01:01,040 --> 00:01:04,160 All right. Thank you. Excuse me, Neil, mate. 18 00:01:04,200 --> 00:01:06,360 Morning, Joy. All right, Ronnie? 19 00:01:06,400 --> 00:01:10,200 So, we've got multiple stab wounds to the chest and stomach. 20 00:01:10,240 --> 00:01:15,680 The wounds are deep, so we're looking for a large blade, possibly a serrated edge. 21 00:01:15,720 --> 00:01:19,160 But at this stage... Too early to tell. You guessed it. 22 00:01:19,200 --> 00:01:22,560 Yeah, well, someone's had a proper go at him, haven't they? 23 00:01:22,600 --> 00:01:24,840 Certainly have. Ronnie... Yeah? 24 00:01:27,200 --> 00:01:29,200 In a sec, Joy. 25 00:01:39,040 --> 00:01:41,080 What we got here, then? 26 00:01:45,920 --> 00:01:48,440 And you say he treats kids? 27 00:01:49,960 --> 00:01:51,560 What is this? A place to sleep? 28 00:01:53,560 --> 00:01:55,600 Or a place for sex? 29 00:01:59,560 --> 00:02:38,372 Subtitles by MemoryOnSmells http://UKsubtitles.ru. 30 00:02:43,320 --> 00:02:45,320 I was... helping my son with his homework. 31 00:02:47,120 --> 00:02:49,000 He's behind on his history project, 32 00:02:49,040 --> 00:02:51,800 so we worked on it together till quite late. 33 00:02:51,840 --> 00:02:54,680 Then I had a bath and went to bed. 34 00:02:56,720 --> 00:02:59,040 And were you expecting your husband home? 35 00:03:01,040 --> 00:03:03,680 His hours can be very erratic. 36 00:03:03,720 --> 00:03:05,840 Sometimes he sleeps in the office. 37 00:03:07,760 --> 00:03:09,560 Right. Whereabouts does he sleep? 38 00:03:10,920 --> 00:03:13,360 On the couch, I suppose. 39 00:03:14,640 --> 00:03:16,760 This morning, I had to get the kids to school. 40 00:03:16,800 --> 00:03:20,360 And then I walked the dogs around Regent's Park. 41 00:03:20,400 --> 00:03:23,400 We're gonna need to speak with your children, 42 00:03:23,440 --> 00:03:25,920 I mean, just to confirm that. 43 00:03:25,960 --> 00:03:28,320 I haven't even told them yet. 44 00:03:28,360 --> 00:03:31,520 Just let us have a little time to adjust, please. 45 00:03:32,640 --> 00:03:34,120 Of course. 46 00:03:34,160 --> 00:03:38,400 Mrs Gardner, you said this morning you took your dogs for a walk round the park. 47 00:03:38,440 --> 00:03:40,040 What did you do after that? 48 00:03:40,080 --> 00:03:42,080 Then I came back... 49 00:03:43,360 --> 00:03:44,680 ..and now you're here. 50 00:03:44,720 --> 00:03:48,120 Mum! They let us come home early! So I missed the French test! 51 00:03:53,240 --> 00:03:54,920 Mum? 52 00:04:02,200 --> 00:04:05,200 DS Brooks, this is Jonathan Shale. 53 00:04:05,240 --> 00:04:09,080 He'll be examining Dr Gardner's patient files for us. 54 00:04:09,120 --> 00:04:13,520 He'll be able to answer any questions without breaching patient-doctor confidentiality. 55 00:04:13,560 --> 00:04:15,000 Really? 56 00:04:15,040 --> 00:04:17,920 So we're not allowed to look into the files ourselves, 57 00:04:17,960 --> 00:04:20,120 but you can and then tell us what's in there? 58 00:04:20,160 --> 00:04:23,720 Well, not everything, of course. But I'll help as best I can. 59 00:04:23,760 --> 00:04:26,320 It is how it is, Ron. 60 00:04:26,360 --> 00:04:30,480 Right. So, he just worked with kids, yeah? 13 and upwards. 61 00:04:30,520 --> 00:04:34,280 Dr Gardner specialised in children with deep emotional issues. 62 00:04:34,320 --> 00:04:36,480 If that's your criteria for finding a suspect, 63 00:04:36,520 --> 00:04:38,480 you've got your hands full. 64 00:04:38,520 --> 00:04:40,760 Ron. Come and look at this. 65 00:04:43,040 --> 00:04:47,080 This is some of the stuff we pulled from the hidden room in Dr Gardner's office. 66 00:04:47,120 --> 00:04:51,240 I've got a loyalty card from a cafe here, 67 00:04:51,280 --> 00:04:54,960 this face cream which costs 200 quid... 68 00:04:55,000 --> 00:04:57,200 What, for moisturiser? Yeah, I know. 69 00:04:57,240 --> 00:04:59,680 And er... And this. What's that? Soap? 70 00:04:59,720 --> 00:05:03,040 No, no. This stuff is skateboard wax. 71 00:05:03,720 --> 00:05:05,200 And this coffee place... 72 00:05:05,240 --> 00:05:08,400 is next door to The Undercroft, on the South Bank. Yeah. 73 00:05:08,440 --> 00:05:11,400 That's a skate park. No, no. It's THE skate park. 74 00:05:11,440 --> 00:05:14,000 Is it really? THE skate park? Very good. 75 00:05:14,040 --> 00:05:17,040 Let me tell you, Joe, that stuff could belong to any number of kids. 76 00:05:17,080 --> 00:05:18,840 Wait. This a good lead. Yeah? 77 00:05:18,880 --> 00:05:22,160 We're not even gonna do down there? And what are we gonna look for, then? 78 00:05:22,200 --> 00:05:25,680 A skateboarder with perfect skin? No. This is a rich girl. 79 00:05:25,720 --> 00:05:28,680 You don't know that's a girl. How long was I at Child Protection? 80 00:05:28,720 --> 00:05:30,640 This is a Jane, not a John. I guarantee it. 81 00:05:30,680 --> 00:05:33,800 This is a rich girl, emotional issues, right? 82 00:05:33,840 --> 00:05:37,120 Hangs out with the skater boys. It's got to be worth a try. 83 00:05:37,160 --> 00:05:39,920 Look, if you're worried, I'll hang back, 84 00:05:39,960 --> 00:05:42,960 you can go and dazzle the kids with your skating skills. Yeah? 85 00:05:43,000 --> 00:05:47,200 Maybe chuck a few ollies, maybe a few grinds? What do you reckon? 86 00:05:49,240 --> 00:05:51,640 Well, you've got some front, I'll give you that. 87 00:05:54,800 --> 00:05:57,440 OK. And where is she, you say? 88 00:05:57,480 --> 00:05:59,440 Over there. The one in the burgundy hat. 89 00:05:59,480 --> 00:06:01,480 In the hat? Yeah. OK. Does she have a name? 90 00:06:01,520 --> 00:06:05,480 Anna. Anna? Yeah. OK. Thanks, lads. Thank you. 91 00:06:09,960 --> 00:06:14,360 Joe? Any luck? 92 00:06:15,400 --> 00:06:18,760 I'm starting to think this wasn't such a good idea. Really? 93 00:06:19,760 --> 00:06:23,360 I thought you was gonna charm them all with your cool talk. Cool talk? 94 00:06:23,400 --> 00:06:25,680 Yeah, you know, being down with the kids. 95 00:06:26,920 --> 00:06:29,760 I don't even know where to start with that. 96 00:06:29,800 --> 00:06:33,760 Well, that's OK. Because Anna does, don't you, Anna? 97 00:06:35,280 --> 00:06:39,040 Well, don't just stand there. Hey! Oi! Police! 98 00:06:40,480 --> 00:06:42,880 Stop. Hey, stop there! 99 00:06:42,920 --> 00:06:45,400 Hey! Hey, slow down! 100 00:06:54,280 --> 00:06:56,200 Hey! Come on! 101 00:07:00,320 --> 00:07:02,880 No! Get away from me! 102 00:07:02,920 --> 00:07:06,320 You can't make me go back. I'm not gonna go back! 103 00:07:06,360 --> 00:07:09,920 Calm down. I'm not gonna hurt you. You can't make me go back to her! 104 00:07:09,960 --> 00:07:11,680 I am not going back to her! 105 00:07:13,840 --> 00:07:15,520 I can't watch her day and night. 106 00:07:15,560 --> 00:07:17,520 No, no, Mrs Sands, I am not judging, 107 00:07:17,560 --> 00:07:19,560 I just need to know where Anna was last night. 108 00:07:19,600 --> 00:07:21,520 I told you, she was staying with a friend. 109 00:07:21,560 --> 00:07:24,400 She's been there all week. She doesn't like my boyfriend. 110 00:07:24,440 --> 00:07:26,360 She doesn't like any of my boyfriends. 111 00:07:26,400 --> 00:07:28,440 So when was the last time you spoke to Anna? 112 00:07:28,480 --> 00:07:30,960 Well, she won't pick up the phone when she knows it's me. 113 00:07:31,000 --> 00:07:34,600 How does she get on with Dr Gardner? Does she see him a lot? 114 00:07:34,640 --> 00:07:37,440 Philip. The wonderful Philip. Yes, she's just fine with him, 115 00:07:37,480 --> 00:07:41,560 but when you're throwing bricks through pub windows and burning the curtains, 116 00:07:41,600 --> 00:07:45,200 you need all the help you can get. So, yeah, she sees him twice a week. 117 00:07:45,240 --> 00:07:49,400 Costs me a small fortune and somehow I'm still a bloody bitch. 118 00:07:49,440 --> 00:07:51,560 No, I'm sorry, I just don't know why I'm here. 119 00:07:51,600 --> 00:07:53,800 So I skipped school. So what? 120 00:08:02,040 --> 00:08:04,000 Hello, Anna. 121 00:08:04,040 --> 00:08:06,040 I've just been talking to your mum. 122 00:08:08,080 --> 00:08:09,920 Whatever she says, it's bollocks. 123 00:08:09,960 --> 00:08:12,360 Well, she was telling me about Dr Gardner. 124 00:08:14,800 --> 00:08:17,640 Yeah? And? 125 00:08:17,680 --> 00:08:20,720 Well, what's he like? 126 00:08:22,280 --> 00:08:24,240 He's the best. 127 00:08:24,280 --> 00:08:27,160 We found some of your things in his office. 128 00:08:27,200 --> 00:08:29,240 Is this about me staying at Philip's? 129 00:08:29,280 --> 00:08:31,840 I thought you were staying with your boyfriend? 130 00:08:32,760 --> 00:08:34,920 OK, wow, you got me. 131 00:08:34,960 --> 00:08:39,000 Look, he told me not to tell anyone. So I... 132 00:08:39,040 --> 00:08:41,760 Why? What did he do? Nothing! 133 00:08:41,800 --> 00:08:44,640 Jeez, you've got such a dirty mind. 134 00:08:44,680 --> 00:08:46,360 So why keep it a secret? 135 00:08:46,400 --> 00:08:50,400 Look, he had strict rules about behaviour and a curfew and all that stuff. 136 00:08:50,440 --> 00:08:54,320 Don't tell me that he's in trouble about this, cos that's just totally unfair. 137 00:09:00,520 --> 00:09:02,440 Dr Gardner died last night, Anna. 138 00:09:05,800 --> 00:09:09,440 He... He was murdered. 139 00:09:12,960 --> 00:09:14,240 No. 140 00:09:14,280 --> 00:09:15,880 No. What... No. 141 00:09:16,800 --> 00:09:20,960 Did he ever talk to you about any of his other patients? You're lying! 142 00:09:21,960 --> 00:09:24,680 I know you're upset, OK? 143 00:09:24,720 --> 00:09:27,960 And I know that he was very, very special to you. 144 00:09:28,000 --> 00:09:33,800 But... you can help him now, by helping us find out who did this. 145 00:09:36,440 --> 00:09:41,000 Anna, this is for Dr Gardner now. Please. Think. 146 00:09:42,560 --> 00:09:44,600 Well... 147 00:09:46,360 --> 00:09:48,360 Well... 148 00:09:50,480 --> 00:09:53,840 There was this... this boy. 149 00:09:54,800 --> 00:09:58,480 I think it must have been one of his patients or something. 150 00:09:59,160 --> 00:10:02,200 And he was... He was gonna bring a knife into school. 151 00:10:03,680 --> 00:10:08,880 But Philip sorted that out, so I don't... 152 00:10:08,920 --> 00:10:10,920 He can't be dead! 153 00:10:13,080 --> 00:10:15,080 He can't be! 154 00:10:21,840 --> 00:10:24,320 Paul? 155 00:10:24,360 --> 00:10:27,040 Paul, for God's sake open the door! 156 00:10:27,080 --> 00:10:29,640 Can I try? Be my guest. 157 00:10:31,040 --> 00:10:33,720 Paul? Hello, mate, it's DS Hawkins. 158 00:10:33,760 --> 00:10:37,080 Listen, I know you've had a real shock, right, 159 00:10:37,120 --> 00:10:40,880 but it's very important that we talk to you about Dr Gardner, OK? 160 00:10:40,920 --> 00:10:44,200 So we just... Dad? Dad, Paul's on his webcam. 161 00:10:46,440 --> 00:10:49,920 And now the police are here. They're saying that Dr Gardner's been murdered. 162 00:10:49,960 --> 00:10:51,720 I-I don't believe it. 163 00:10:51,760 --> 00:10:53,840 I trusted him. 164 00:10:54,520 --> 00:10:57,200 He said everything was gonna to be OK. 165 00:10:57,240 --> 00:10:59,920 But now it just feels like everything's gone black again. 166 00:11:05,840 --> 00:11:09,000 Jesus! Shit! 167 00:11:16,760 --> 00:11:19,440 Just let me die! Just let me be with Philip! 168 00:11:19,480 --> 00:11:23,200 Stay calm! Stay calm. Ssh, that's it. 169 00:11:25,360 --> 00:11:28,360 I wanna be with Philip! I don't wanna do it any more! 170 00:11:29,478 --> 00:11:32,958 Mr Downing, was Paul with you the whole night Dr Gardner died? 171 00:11:36,238 --> 00:11:39,318 Well, no, he was... 172 00:11:39,358 --> 00:11:43,518 Since he was taken off the medication, 173 00:11:43,558 --> 00:11:45,838 he goes out for walks at night to clear his head. 174 00:11:45,878 --> 00:11:47,958 What do you mean, sorry? 175 00:11:49,598 --> 00:11:52,318 Dr Gardner took him off the medication. 176 00:11:53,878 --> 00:11:58,838 I know he's a very good psychiatrist, but... that scared me. 177 00:11:58,878 --> 00:12:01,078 And that's why I stopped the sessions. 178 00:12:01,958 --> 00:12:03,958 And how did Paul feel about that? 179 00:12:05,558 --> 00:12:06,958 He went ape. 180 00:12:06,998 --> 00:12:09,278 Right... 181 00:12:09,318 --> 00:12:14,118 Er, they're transferring your son to the psychiatric ward now. 182 00:12:22,158 --> 00:12:24,118 What do you reckon? 183 00:12:24,158 --> 00:12:27,478 Well, Paul seemed pretty upset when we told him Gardner was dead. 184 00:12:27,518 --> 00:12:29,518 Yeah, he did. 185 00:12:30,238 --> 00:12:33,878 I just don't like the way all them kids love that doctor so much. 186 00:12:33,918 --> 00:12:36,638 You think he was abusing Paul? I don't know. Maybe. 187 00:12:36,678 --> 00:12:38,678 Paul's got no alibi, though, Joe. 188 00:12:39,918 --> 00:12:41,878 You take a mentally unstable lad, 189 00:12:41,918 --> 00:12:44,358 mess with his pills, what happens then? 190 00:12:45,438 --> 00:12:47,918 I think it's completely irresponsible. 191 00:12:47,958 --> 00:12:50,638 Paul can't survive without a certain level of medication. 192 00:12:50,678 --> 00:12:54,438 I'm just not a fan of kids being doped if it can be avoided. 193 00:12:54,478 --> 00:12:56,398 Nor me. But if you study Paul's case notes, 194 00:12:56,438 --> 00:12:58,118 you'd see there's no other option. 195 00:12:58,158 --> 00:13:01,958 Why Dr Gardner decided to throw it all out the window is beyond me. 196 00:13:01,998 --> 00:13:04,918 Paul seemed to like his methods. He's a child. 197 00:13:04,958 --> 00:13:07,318 He's a teenager, but he's still easily influenced. 198 00:13:07,358 --> 00:13:11,998 So Dr Carey, you don't think Dr Gardner's methods helped Paul at all? 199 00:13:12,038 --> 00:13:13,438 No, I don't. 200 00:13:13,478 --> 00:13:16,918 Kids love doctors like Gardner because they break the rules. 201 00:13:16,958 --> 00:13:20,158 But it's irresponsible, and Paul's breakdown is all the proof you need. 202 00:13:20,198 --> 00:13:22,038 How do you think Paul would react, then, 203 00:13:22,078 --> 00:13:25,678 if Dr Gardner had told him he was gonna get better, then he didn't? 204 00:13:25,718 --> 00:13:26,838 Not well. 205 00:13:27,958 --> 00:13:30,678 Where were you two nights ago, Paul? 206 00:13:30,718 --> 00:13:33,878 I was just walking around. Thinking. 207 00:13:33,918 --> 00:13:36,278 Did you go and see Dr Gardner? 208 00:13:37,398 --> 00:13:39,398 I just walked in circles. 209 00:13:40,598 --> 00:13:43,318 My head gets so busy. 210 00:13:43,358 --> 00:13:46,438 Is that because Dr Gardner messed up your treatment? 211 00:13:46,478 --> 00:13:48,478 He didn't mess with anything. 212 00:13:49,798 --> 00:13:51,598 Tell us what we've got wrong, then. 213 00:13:51,638 --> 00:13:55,238 'I am a rock in a sea of chaos.' 214 00:13:57,118 --> 00:14:00,398 Philip taught me that. It's what I say to myself. 215 00:14:00,438 --> 00:14:04,078 I go walking in the dark and I say it over and over. 216 00:14:05,118 --> 00:14:06,678 He helped calm me down. 217 00:14:06,718 --> 00:14:10,398 Don't you feel calmer now that you're back on your medication? 218 00:14:10,438 --> 00:14:13,918 I suppose. But I feel shit. 219 00:14:13,958 --> 00:14:16,678 You took a knife to school, Paul. 220 00:14:16,718 --> 00:14:21,518 I went to the school and my brain was on fire... 221 00:14:21,558 --> 00:14:24,638 and I was just going to stab everyone, just stab them all, 222 00:14:24,678 --> 00:14:28,958 but... But I remembered what Philip had taught me. 223 00:14:28,998 --> 00:14:32,838 I'm a rock... in a sea of chaos. 224 00:14:34,758 --> 00:14:36,758 And it stopped me. 225 00:14:37,638 --> 00:14:39,478 He saved me, see? 226 00:14:41,038 --> 00:14:44,358 Where's the knife now, Paul? I gave it to Philip. 227 00:14:45,798 --> 00:14:50,078 He locked it in his desk. To keep us all safe. 228 00:14:52,598 --> 00:14:56,518 If there had been a knife, our guys would have found it during the original search. 229 00:14:56,558 --> 00:14:58,798 No, you're right. 230 00:14:58,838 --> 00:15:03,158 Oh, and, er, CCTV picked up Paul wandering around the park, 231 00:15:03,198 --> 00:15:05,358 so he's in the clear. Right. 232 00:15:05,398 --> 00:15:07,398 OK. 233 00:15:07,438 --> 00:15:09,278 Joe! 234 00:15:11,678 --> 00:15:15,198 Well, no knife, but... what have we got here? 235 00:15:21,438 --> 00:15:22,518 Clare. 236 00:15:24,478 --> 00:15:26,478 Right... 237 00:15:33,118 --> 00:15:35,118 'The taste of your skin, 238 00:15:35,718 --> 00:15:39,998 of your perfect, unblemished body... 239 00:15:40,558 --> 00:15:42,278 ..made me forget about everything. 240 00:15:42,318 --> 00:15:45,638 It didn't matter if people could see us through the glass. 241 00:15:45,678 --> 00:15:49,878 I don't care what they say. I want you. 242 00:15:49,918 --> 00:15:52,038 I want YOU. 243 00:15:52,078 --> 00:15:54,878 I have to have you, whatever the consequences.' 244 00:15:56,718 --> 00:15:59,758 Who is this Clare? We don't know. 245 00:15:59,798 --> 00:16:02,318 There is no Clare listed among his clients 246 00:16:02,358 --> 00:16:05,158 and she doesn't speak on the tape. Not once? 247 00:16:05,198 --> 00:16:08,318 To be honest, guv, we're not really sure what these tapes are. 248 00:16:08,358 --> 00:16:11,438 Or who she is. We've just got a Christian name and a rough age group. 249 00:16:11,478 --> 00:16:13,758 If she was underage, he'd have wanted to hide her. 250 00:16:13,798 --> 00:16:18,758 Look, guv, we can always go back and re-interview all of his female clients, 251 00:16:18,798 --> 00:16:21,958 see if Clare's a nickname for one of them. Good luck with that. 252 00:16:21,998 --> 00:16:24,278 What else? We're still not able to see his kids. 253 00:16:24,318 --> 00:16:26,438 What, his wife's in the way? Yeah. 254 00:16:26,478 --> 00:16:29,638 Strange, that, because they're the ones that can confirm her alibi. 255 00:16:29,678 --> 00:16:32,558 It don't add up, Wes. I think she's lying. 256 00:16:32,598 --> 00:16:35,278 She won't like it. I don't care. Do it. 257 00:16:38,238 --> 00:16:40,918 - Whatever Mum said. - OK. 258 00:16:40,958 --> 00:16:43,838 It would be good to hear it from you, though. Riley? 259 00:16:47,038 --> 00:16:51,198 Hey, Riley's an unusual name. It's my mum's maiden name. 260 00:16:51,238 --> 00:16:54,078 Sorry? It's my maiden name. 261 00:16:54,118 --> 00:16:56,318 Oh. Original. 262 00:16:59,278 --> 00:17:02,598 Er, so, anything else can you tell us about that night? 263 00:17:02,638 --> 00:17:06,478 We just... did my homework together. 264 00:17:07,518 --> 00:17:09,838 It took ages. And then I went to bed. 265 00:17:09,878 --> 00:17:12,798 That's good. That's helpful, Riley. 266 00:17:12,838 --> 00:17:15,158 What time was it? 267 00:17:17,238 --> 00:17:19,958 10:15. 268 00:17:20,838 --> 00:17:22,838 10:15? 269 00:17:23,838 --> 00:17:27,398 That's pretty precise. How do you know that? 270 00:17:27,438 --> 00:17:30,118 It all happened just like Mum said. 271 00:17:33,478 --> 00:17:36,318 Well, that's really helpful, Riley. Thank you very much. 272 00:17:36,358 --> 00:17:38,678 I'd like to talk to Lisa now, if that's OK? 273 00:17:39,958 --> 00:17:42,278 Erm, I'm afraid she's still at school. 274 00:17:42,318 --> 00:17:45,198 She wanted to get some things, be with her friends for a while. 275 00:17:45,238 --> 00:17:48,558 If you come back... No, that's fine, we'll go to the school, 276 00:17:48,598 --> 00:17:50,398 talk to her there. I'll come with you. 277 00:17:50,438 --> 00:17:53,358 That's OK. Thanks, Mrs Gardner. We can handle that. 278 00:17:59,518 --> 00:18:02,118 I was in my room. Mum and Riley were downstairs. 279 00:18:03,358 --> 00:18:05,798 Doing his homework? 280 00:18:08,918 --> 00:18:11,358 Lisa? Yes. Doing that. 281 00:18:13,198 --> 00:18:14,678 See, I don't think so. 282 00:18:15,878 --> 00:18:21,118 Now, why are you lying to us? What did Riley say? 283 00:18:23,318 --> 00:18:25,998 Look, Lisa, you've gotta help us out here. 284 00:18:33,198 --> 00:18:36,158 He came into my room. 285 00:18:37,558 --> 00:18:40,278 OK, when was that? I don't know. Late. 286 00:18:41,318 --> 00:18:45,398 He'd gone to bed, and he woke up. He gets these nightmares and... 287 00:18:45,438 --> 00:18:48,358 he was looking for Mum. And...? 288 00:18:48,398 --> 00:18:51,918 And he couldn't find her, so we went looking together. 289 00:18:51,958 --> 00:18:53,798 You didn't find her, did you? 290 00:19:00,598 --> 00:19:02,318 Do you think... 291 00:19:02,358 --> 00:19:04,358 What? 292 00:19:06,438 --> 00:19:08,118 Do you think she did it? 293 00:19:10,798 --> 00:19:13,758 Your daughter made a statement. You forced her to. 294 00:19:13,798 --> 00:19:16,798 Where were you on the night of the murder? My client answered this. 295 00:19:16,838 --> 00:19:20,758 Did it bother you that he was spending so much time with young, impressionable girls? 296 00:19:20,798 --> 00:19:23,198 It was his job. Who's Clare? 297 00:19:23,238 --> 00:19:25,038 I don't know. 298 00:19:25,078 --> 00:19:28,718 Why is there a secret room in your husband's office? I don't know! I think you do. 299 00:19:30,318 --> 00:19:32,758 I'm going to play you a tape recording that we found. 300 00:19:34,798 --> 00:19:39,318 'I am willing to break every rule and every vow for you. 301 00:19:39,358 --> 00:19:41,998 Nothing else matters. 302 00:19:42,038 --> 00:19:45,718 How can it when our feelings are so strong -' TURN IT OFF! 303 00:19:58,438 --> 00:20:01,358 Rock in a sea of chaos. I am a rock in a sea of chaos. 304 00:20:01,398 --> 00:20:04,478 I am a rock in a sea of chaos. I am a rock in a sea of chaos. 305 00:20:04,518 --> 00:20:06,398 I am a rock in a sea of chaos... 306 00:20:11,118 --> 00:20:14,158 Jonathan, how far back does the list of patients go? 307 00:20:14,198 --> 00:20:16,038 I've got over 20 years of cases here. 308 00:20:16,078 --> 00:20:18,358 Could you show me the first ones, please? 309 00:20:19,358 --> 00:20:21,518 Yep. Brilliant. 310 00:20:22,518 --> 00:20:24,518 Ta. 311 00:20:30,958 --> 00:20:32,958 Great. 312 00:20:45,398 --> 00:20:47,718 Alison, were you a patient of Dr Gardner? 313 00:20:52,678 --> 00:20:55,398 Have you ever been a patient of Dr Gardner? What's that? 314 00:20:57,118 --> 00:21:00,638 Is that my file? How old were you when he treated you? 315 00:21:00,678 --> 00:21:03,598 That's my file. He can't see that, he's not allowed. 316 00:21:03,638 --> 00:21:05,598 Were you young? 317 00:21:09,238 --> 00:21:14,598 I was 15. And did you fall in love with him whilst he was treating you? 318 00:21:14,638 --> 00:21:16,958 I really don't want to talk about this. 319 00:21:16,998 --> 00:21:20,278 Well, you reacted very strongly when we played that tape. 320 00:21:20,318 --> 00:21:23,638 Was it because it reminded you of your experiences with Dr Gardner? 321 00:21:24,678 --> 00:21:27,438 Is he doing it again? Replacing you with a younger model? 322 00:21:27,478 --> 00:21:29,478 He doesn't love her. 323 00:21:29,518 --> 00:21:31,198 And she doesn't love him. 324 00:21:32,558 --> 00:21:33,838 And how do you know this? 325 00:21:33,878 --> 00:21:36,478 He's just acting without control or discipline. 326 00:21:39,838 --> 00:21:42,798 You've heard these tapes before! The actions of a diseased mind. 327 00:21:42,838 --> 00:21:47,318 I don't understand. No, but there's no point trying to make him better. 328 00:21:50,918 --> 00:21:52,278 What did you do? 329 00:21:56,438 --> 00:22:00,318 Alison? You killed your husband... 330 00:22:00,358 --> 00:22:04,958 because you knew he was abusing a teenage girl. Didn't you? 331 00:22:07,838 --> 00:22:09,838 That's right, isn't it? 332 00:22:12,118 --> 00:22:15,078 Your silence isn't helping you, Alison, you know that? 333 00:22:15,118 --> 00:22:17,598 You think it is, but it isn't. You are wrong. 334 00:22:18,678 --> 00:22:22,118 I'm arresting you on suspicion of the murder of Philip Gardner. 335 00:22:32,198 --> 00:22:34,398 Hello. You gone mad? 336 00:22:34,438 --> 00:22:37,838 You can't start waving a patient's case file around. 337 00:22:37,878 --> 00:22:39,838 Guv... No, no. 338 00:22:39,878 --> 00:22:41,958 This is confidential information. 339 00:22:41,998 --> 00:22:44,318 They're gonna kick this straight out of court. 340 00:22:44,358 --> 00:22:46,398 I didn't use any confidential information. 341 00:22:46,438 --> 00:22:50,958 And Wes, I just asked questions, she answered them. Right, Joe? 342 00:22:50,998 --> 00:22:53,878 Yes, OK, but the file was in your hand. What, Wes? 343 00:22:53,918 --> 00:22:55,678 Oh, I'm sorry, what, this file? Yes. 344 00:22:55,718 --> 00:22:57,758 This isn't Alison Gardner's file. 345 00:22:57,798 --> 00:23:00,478 I just picked this up on my way through to the interview room. 346 00:23:00,518 --> 00:23:02,998 Why? Did it seem like it was her file? I'm sorry. 347 00:23:08,798 --> 00:23:10,798 You still need to find Clare. 348 00:23:15,115 --> 00:23:18,155 Morning, Jake. Vijay. 349 00:23:18,195 --> 00:23:23,115 We're up against each soon. I'm defending Alison Gardner. 350 00:23:23,155 --> 00:23:26,235 Yes, I saw that she'd hired you. I look forward to it. 351 00:23:26,275 --> 00:23:28,915 Me too, Jake. Me too. 352 00:23:30,155 --> 00:23:32,875 'I can't believe the daughter has changed her statement. 353 00:23:32,915 --> 00:23:36,715 How did they get the girl to retract? She's 16 and she loves her mum. 354 00:23:36,755 --> 00:23:39,835 Won't have been hard to persuade her that she got her dates muddled. 355 00:23:39,875 --> 00:23:43,035 So now we have no witness to contradict Alison Gardner's alibi. 356 00:23:43,075 --> 00:23:46,395 No witness, no weapon, she's still maintaining her innocence, 357 00:23:46,435 --> 00:23:48,955 and we're no closer to finding Clare, whoever she is. 358 00:23:48,995 --> 00:23:51,635 Without Lisa's evidence, we're stuffed. I'm reassured. 359 00:23:51,675 --> 00:23:53,835 I'm working on it. What else? 360 00:23:53,875 --> 00:23:56,035 The police have look at Alison's phone records. 361 00:23:56,075 --> 00:24:00,275 She made only one call the morning after Dr Gardner died. To her mum. 362 00:24:03,035 --> 00:24:06,395 I know it must be difficult, Mrs Riley... I have nothing to say to you. 363 00:24:06,435 --> 00:24:09,835 No, but Mrs Riley... She's a good girl now. 364 00:24:12,235 --> 00:24:16,155 Mrs Riley, the phone call, the morning after when she... 365 00:24:16,195 --> 00:24:19,675 She didn't do it. Philip had put an end to all that. 366 00:24:19,715 --> 00:24:24,635 She must have caused you a lot of worry, with the trouble she'd got into, yeah? 367 00:24:24,675 --> 00:24:29,075 That's a nice way of putting it. She still blames me. 368 00:24:30,355 --> 00:24:33,435 But I wasn't the one out all night, blind drunk with my legs in the air. 369 00:24:33,475 --> 00:24:36,755 But Dr Gardner helped her, though, yeah? No, he saved her. 370 00:24:38,355 --> 00:24:42,995 Everyone tutted because she was so young - I mean she was just 15. 371 00:24:43,035 --> 00:24:46,275 But the shame of that, of them, that I could live with. 372 00:24:46,315 --> 00:24:49,635 Did they ever fight? No more than any other couple. 373 00:24:49,675 --> 00:24:53,955 The phone call, the morning after, did she seem distressed at all? 374 00:24:53,995 --> 00:24:55,915 Well, you can hear for yourself. 375 00:24:57,475 --> 00:25:00,635 I'm sorry, I don't understand. I wasn't in when she phoned. 376 00:25:00,675 --> 00:25:03,475 She left a message. It's on the machine. 377 00:25:08,195 --> 00:25:12,635 You know, Lisa, we were very surprised when we heard that you'd changed your statement. 378 00:25:12,675 --> 00:25:15,315 I just got things muddled up. 379 00:25:15,355 --> 00:25:18,555 It's just, you seemed very clear when we spoke to you before. 380 00:25:18,595 --> 00:25:21,595 I just got things wrong. That's all. 381 00:25:21,635 --> 00:25:24,075 I understand that you want to protect your mother. 382 00:25:24,115 --> 00:25:27,075 It's a good instinct. But I'm not like the police, Lisa. 383 00:25:27,115 --> 00:25:29,355 I have to fight for my cases. 384 00:25:29,395 --> 00:25:33,395 And if you won't speak, then I'm gonna have to call your brother to the witness box. 385 00:25:33,435 --> 00:25:37,235 I don't think Riley would cope very well, all alone in court, 386 00:25:37,275 --> 00:25:39,435 having to see his mother in the dock. Do you? 387 00:25:39,475 --> 00:25:41,435 I don't know what to do. 388 00:25:41,475 --> 00:25:43,715 It's OK, Lisa. Just tell me what really happened. 389 00:25:44,515 --> 00:25:46,155 It's all my fault! 390 00:25:48,755 --> 00:25:50,755 I found the tape in Dad's office. 391 00:25:53,355 --> 00:25:55,715 I was snooping. 392 00:25:55,755 --> 00:25:59,435 Stupid because his patients often have really cool things and... 393 00:26:03,515 --> 00:26:05,515 I played it and it was... 394 00:26:05,555 --> 00:26:07,475 disgusting. 395 00:26:08,995 --> 00:26:10,515 It freaked me out. 396 00:26:10,555 --> 00:26:15,195 I tried to hide it, but Mum came in and she saw I was crying and... 397 00:26:18,155 --> 00:26:20,195 I shouldn't have let her hear it. 398 00:26:21,675 --> 00:26:23,635 I know what she's like. 399 00:26:23,675 --> 00:26:26,635 If I'd have just put it back... 400 00:26:31,195 --> 00:26:33,115 It's all my fault. 401 00:26:34,995 --> 00:26:38,115 'Hi, Mum. It's just me. I wondered if you'd heard from Philip. 402 00:26:38,155 --> 00:26:41,715 He didn't come home last night. Hope you're OK. Bye.' 403 00:26:42,795 --> 00:26:45,595 I'm sorry, how is this helpful? Listen in the background. 404 00:26:45,635 --> 00:26:48,275 'Hi, Mum. It's just me. 405 00:26:48,315 --> 00:26:53,315 I wondered if you'd heard from Philip. He didn't come home last night. Hope you're OK. Bye.' 406 00:26:53,355 --> 00:26:56,195 That doesn't sound like Regent's Park. No, it doesn't. 407 00:26:56,235 --> 00:27:01,315 Well, she can say what she likes, but cell site towers show Mrs Gardner was nowhere near the park. 408 00:27:01,355 --> 00:27:03,395 She was somewhere around St Pancras. 409 00:27:03,435 --> 00:27:08,995 Forensic audio have managed to isolate and enhance some of the specific sounds from the tape. 410 00:27:09,035 --> 00:27:10,395 This... 411 00:27:10,435 --> 00:27:15,595 'Hi, Mum. It's just me.' 412 00:27:17,075 --> 00:27:18,355 ..is a train. 413 00:27:18,395 --> 00:27:21,315 Also - and this is a bit odd 414 00:27:21,355 --> 00:27:23,835 they've picked up what sounds like a winching noise. 415 00:27:31,155 --> 00:27:33,835 Around St Pancras, you say? Yeah. 416 00:27:35,875 --> 00:27:39,675 I need two officers stationed each side of the bridge, that side of it now. 417 00:27:39,715 --> 00:27:40,875 Joe? 418 00:27:40,915 --> 00:27:44,315 They've got her on closed circuit, walking away from Goodsway Bridge. 419 00:27:44,355 --> 00:27:46,875 Guys, we're gonna to have to look further along, yeah? 420 00:27:52,435 --> 00:27:55,355 Joe, do us a favour, mate. Stop fidgeting, will you? 421 00:27:55,395 --> 00:27:58,315 You should put this time to good use anyway. Like? 422 00:27:58,355 --> 00:28:01,915 Like thinking of a way we can find this Clare. 423 00:28:01,955 --> 00:28:05,155 I've searched all the national databases for missing persons, 424 00:28:05,195 --> 00:28:07,235 I've talked to all of his patients. 425 00:28:15,275 --> 00:28:20,395 We now have the knife whose serrated blade and size could have caused the wounds on Dr Gardner's body. 426 00:28:20,435 --> 00:28:23,835 Could have? A knife that we can prove was in Dr Gardner's office. 427 00:28:23,875 --> 00:28:27,835 It was recovered close by where Mrs Gardner was seen on CCTV. 428 00:28:27,875 --> 00:28:29,635 Does it show her holding this knife? 429 00:28:29,675 --> 00:28:34,715 It shows her in the vicinity and not in Regent's Park, as she previously claimed. 430 00:28:34,755 --> 00:28:37,835 What DNA is there to link my client with this knife? 431 00:28:37,875 --> 00:28:41,075 Because we all know the water will mean you have no real evidence. 432 00:28:41,115 --> 00:28:43,995 I'm satisfied that we have more than enough. So am I. 433 00:28:47,075 --> 00:28:50,115 It's all circumstantial. We've convicted on less. 434 00:28:50,155 --> 00:28:52,995 A jury's gonna wonder why Mrs Gardner lied to the police. 435 00:28:53,035 --> 00:28:55,275 And we'll point out just how often she did. 436 00:28:55,315 --> 00:28:58,395 Look, I appreciate your disclosure, but really - I was raped. 437 00:29:00,035 --> 00:29:02,315 I was 15. And he raped me. Hang on... 438 00:29:02,355 --> 00:29:06,155 When I found out he was going to do it again, all over again, I couldn't breathe. 439 00:29:06,195 --> 00:29:08,715 This is not - I was so scared of what would happen to Clare. 440 00:29:08,755 --> 00:29:13,475 I felt sick, so I ran to him to confront him and to stop him. 441 00:29:13,515 --> 00:29:17,595 But then, I don't know, I just, I lost control. 442 00:29:17,635 --> 00:29:19,715 I stabbed him. 443 00:29:21,955 --> 00:29:25,195 Mrs Gardner, do you understand the implications of what you're saying? 444 00:29:25,235 --> 00:29:27,995 Of course she doesn't! It wasn't murder. 445 00:29:28,035 --> 00:29:31,115 You want to change your plea to guilty of manslaughter? 446 00:29:31,155 --> 00:29:33,715 No! Yes. 447 00:29:33,755 --> 00:29:35,715 Yes, that's right. I do. 448 00:29:41,075 --> 00:29:44,275 I can't believe they thought we'd just go for a manslaughter plea. 449 00:29:44,315 --> 00:29:46,315 Is it really such a bad idea? 450 00:29:47,315 --> 00:29:49,715 At least we'd avoid the trial and the cost. 451 00:29:49,755 --> 00:29:51,835 There's less damage to the children. 452 00:29:51,875 --> 00:29:55,995 You'd accept her plea? Over loss of control? Yeah, I would. 453 00:29:56,035 --> 00:29:58,555 The repeated rape clearly qualifies as a trigger, 454 00:29:58,595 --> 00:30:00,515 and the jury's gonna empathise with her. 455 00:30:00,555 --> 00:30:04,355 So you think Dr Gardner raped her? I do, yeah. 456 00:30:06,195 --> 00:30:09,955 Oh, come on! A mattress in a secret room? 457 00:30:09,995 --> 00:30:11,515 It's not right. 458 00:30:11,555 --> 00:30:15,635 She stabbed him. Over and over and over and over. 459 00:30:15,675 --> 00:30:18,435 Seven times. Not once or twice. Seven. 460 00:30:18,475 --> 00:30:20,835 Loss of control? Maybe. 461 00:30:20,875 --> 00:30:22,835 But she must have been covered in blood. 462 00:30:22,875 --> 00:30:24,715 Yet she walked away, changed her clothes 463 00:30:24,755 --> 00:30:27,995 and had the presence of mind to dump them somewhere, we don't know where. 464 00:30:28,035 --> 00:30:30,235 Like the tape she heard. Precisely disposed of. 465 00:30:30,275 --> 00:30:34,275 And then she sent that message to her mother and took her children to school. 466 00:30:34,315 --> 00:30:35,835 Made them lie on her behalf. 467 00:30:35,875 --> 00:30:39,595 And then, only because we finally found the knife, did she change her story. 468 00:30:41,155 --> 00:30:44,555 I understand why you feel like that. Alison's a very sympathetic figure. 469 00:30:44,595 --> 00:30:47,755 But she knew exactly what she was doing. 470 00:30:47,795 --> 00:30:50,195 But we have to make the jury see it's murder. 471 00:30:53,795 --> 00:30:57,155 Could you tell the court where you were on that evening? I was at home. 472 00:30:57,195 --> 00:30:59,075 And what were you doing at home? 473 00:30:59,115 --> 00:31:02,035 We had dinner, Mum and Riley, like we always do. 474 00:31:02,075 --> 00:31:05,075 And then I did my homework and stayed in my room. All night? 475 00:31:06,155 --> 00:31:08,155 No, I... 476 00:31:09,035 --> 00:31:13,475 I was on my computer, chatting to friends and stuff, and then Riley came in. 477 00:31:13,515 --> 00:31:17,515 And what did he want? He wanted to know where Mum was. 478 00:31:17,555 --> 00:31:20,755 And where was she? We couldn't find her. 479 00:31:20,795 --> 00:31:24,755 When did you notice she was gone? About ten, I think. 480 00:31:24,795 --> 00:31:27,475 And when did she get back? 481 00:31:27,515 --> 00:31:29,155 I don't know. 482 00:31:29,195 --> 00:31:31,555 Lisa? 483 00:31:31,595 --> 00:31:33,155 I didn't see her till the morning. 484 00:31:33,195 --> 00:31:35,915 But your mother said that she was with you the whole time. 485 00:31:35,955 --> 00:31:37,915 Your Honour. 486 00:31:37,955 --> 00:31:42,435 Mr Thorne, is there an actual question you would like to ask the witness? 487 00:31:42,475 --> 00:31:43,675 Thank you, Your Honour. 488 00:31:43,715 --> 00:31:46,915 No, Your Honour, she's said everything she should. 489 00:31:46,955 --> 00:31:51,915 It's OK, my love. I love you, Lisa. I love you too, Mum. 490 00:31:51,955 --> 00:31:56,715 Please, Mrs Gardner, I cannot allow - I'm sorry. Sorry. 491 00:31:56,755 --> 00:31:59,115 I need to get this to Mr Prasad. 492 00:32:05,675 --> 00:32:07,555 Thank you. 493 00:32:12,235 --> 00:32:14,995 Mr Prasad? Yes, Your Honour, I'm sorry. 494 00:32:15,035 --> 00:32:17,155 Um... Yeah. 495 00:32:17,195 --> 00:32:18,435 OK, right. 496 00:32:21,595 --> 00:32:25,635 Lisa, tell us about the time that your mother planted lilies in your front garden. 497 00:32:25,675 --> 00:32:29,275 I don't want to. It's OK, it's fine. Mrs Gardner, please! 498 00:32:29,315 --> 00:32:33,555 Lisa? Mum planted flowers, 499 00:32:33,595 --> 00:32:35,795 two rows all the way from the gate to the door. 500 00:32:36,595 --> 00:32:38,715 But when Dad came home, he was really angry. 501 00:32:38,755 --> 00:32:42,195 And what did he do? He ripped them up. 502 00:32:42,235 --> 00:32:43,955 Why? 503 00:32:43,995 --> 00:32:45,995 Why did he rip them up, Lisa? 504 00:32:46,035 --> 00:32:48,675 Dad said that... she didn't have permission. 505 00:32:48,715 --> 00:32:51,515 He treated me like a child, didn't he? Mrs Gardner! 506 00:32:51,555 --> 00:32:55,195 I am being as patient as I can in these circumstances. I'm sorry. 507 00:32:55,235 --> 00:32:58,595 But I will not have this case overrun by you. 508 00:32:58,635 --> 00:33:02,275 You will respect this courtroom or you will be removed from it. 509 00:33:02,315 --> 00:33:04,875 Is that clear? Mr Prasad. 510 00:33:04,915 --> 00:33:06,635 Thank you, Your Honour. 511 00:33:06,675 --> 00:33:11,915 Is it correct that you were the person who found the tape? Yes. 512 00:33:11,955 --> 00:33:14,355 And you showed it to your mother? Yes. 513 00:33:15,275 --> 00:33:17,755 And how did she react when she heard the recording? 514 00:33:18,875 --> 00:33:22,715 She went quiet and locked herself in the loo. Thank you, Lisa. 515 00:33:24,515 --> 00:33:26,875 One last question, Lisa, and then you're done. 516 00:33:26,915 --> 00:33:29,995 Did you ever hear your mother tell your father that she loved him? 517 00:33:30,035 --> 00:33:31,795 Yes, of course. Lots of times. 518 00:33:37,075 --> 00:33:39,475 What do the jury make of it? I think they like her. 519 00:33:39,515 --> 00:33:41,635 They love her! There's something else. 520 00:33:41,675 --> 00:33:44,715 The defence have called up a child psychiatrist, Dr Anthonia Carey, 521 00:33:44,755 --> 00:33:47,195 to give evidence in support of Alison. Saying what? 522 00:33:47,235 --> 00:33:50,555 Emphasising the ongoing trauma of childhood abuse in adult life. 523 00:33:50,595 --> 00:33:52,995 Oh, no, this is bad. 524 00:33:53,035 --> 00:33:54,555 Yes, that's what I thought. 525 00:33:54,595 --> 00:33:57,035 We're going from guilty of murder with a life sentence 526 00:33:57,075 --> 00:34:00,475 to manslaughter on grounds of loss of control. With good behaviour... 527 00:34:00,515 --> 00:34:02,795 She can be very well behaved when she needs to be. 528 00:34:02,835 --> 00:34:05,195 ..I can see her being back out in two years. 529 00:34:05,235 --> 00:34:07,715 What do we know about this Dr Carey? 530 00:34:07,755 --> 00:34:09,755 She is smart and principled. 531 00:34:09,795 --> 00:34:12,195 When we brought in the lad who'd tried to kill himself, 532 00:34:12,235 --> 00:34:15,835 she made it very clear she had no time for Philip Gardner's methods. 533 00:34:15,875 --> 00:34:19,635 You think this is personal? She just felt the boy in her care had been mistreated. 534 00:34:19,675 --> 00:34:22,795 But the guy's dead, I don't know why she wants to tread the dirt in. 535 00:34:22,835 --> 00:34:25,555 Her motivation isn't important. Will she damage the case? 536 00:34:25,595 --> 00:34:28,195 She'll convince the jury. She comes across very well. 537 00:34:28,235 --> 00:34:29,835 She does, doesn't she? 538 00:34:31,315 --> 00:34:32,915 No news of Clare? 539 00:34:32,955 --> 00:34:36,795 Joe's out now trying all the homeless shelters, hostels. 540 00:34:36,835 --> 00:34:38,595 When we know, you'll know. 541 00:34:38,635 --> 00:34:40,955 I appreciate your efforts, Ronnie. 542 00:34:58,035 --> 00:35:00,035 OK. 543 00:35:01,315 --> 00:35:03,155 I think I can help you. 544 00:35:06,356 --> 00:35:09,836 Dr Gardner abused the privileges of his profession. 545 00:35:09,964 --> 00:35:13,644 There is never an excuse for sexual relationships with your patients. 546 00:35:13,684 --> 00:35:16,004 It is an absolute betrayal of trust. 547 00:35:16,044 --> 00:35:21,564 If you break that trust, then your behaviour can have tragic and even violent consequences. 548 00:35:21,604 --> 00:35:24,564 Even much later on in life? Absolutely. 549 00:35:24,604 --> 00:35:26,604 Thank you, Dr Carey. 550 00:35:27,964 --> 00:35:30,964 Dr Carey, do you have examples of these cases 551 00:35:31,004 --> 00:35:34,524 where violence followed the sexual interaction between doctor and patient? 552 00:35:34,564 --> 00:35:36,204 I do. 553 00:35:36,244 --> 00:35:39,644 And of these cases, how many of the abused patients 554 00:35:39,684 --> 00:35:42,644 went on to marry the adult with whom they had sex? 555 00:35:43,924 --> 00:35:45,364 I don't know of any, but - 556 00:35:45,404 --> 00:35:50,084 How about those where doctor and patient remained married for 20 years 557 00:35:50,124 --> 00:35:54,244 and raised two happy and well-balanced children? 558 00:35:54,284 --> 00:35:55,324 None. 559 00:35:55,364 --> 00:35:59,044 But Dr Gardner was in a position whereby he could convince Alison 560 00:35:59,084 --> 00:36:01,364 she was in love with him, even if this wasn't true. 561 00:36:01,404 --> 00:36:06,644 So are you certain that Dr Gardner crossed a line when he had sex with Alison? 562 00:36:06,684 --> 00:36:09,444 Yes, it's unforgivable. Have you ever done the same? 563 00:36:09,484 --> 00:36:11,324 Of course not. 564 00:36:11,364 --> 00:36:13,924 Never? No. 565 00:36:16,484 --> 00:36:19,804 When you were much younger, quite early on in your career, 566 00:36:19,844 --> 00:36:25,284 is it right that you used to counsel members of the legal profession after traumatic cases? 567 00:36:25,324 --> 00:36:28,524 I did. Did you ever sleep with a patient? 568 00:36:30,484 --> 00:36:34,684 How about a young solicitor who was deeply affected by a harrowing case 569 00:36:34,724 --> 00:36:37,764 involving the death of a key witness? 570 00:36:37,804 --> 00:36:39,924 I... 571 00:36:39,964 --> 00:36:46,124 Yes, but only once and I should stress that the man was not a child. 572 00:36:46,164 --> 00:36:49,964 He was 31. But you betrayed his trust all the same, surely? 573 00:36:51,124 --> 00:36:55,924 Dr Carey? Weren't you worried about the tragic and violent consequences that may follow? 574 00:37:14,924 --> 00:37:16,684 That was a low blow. 575 00:37:19,084 --> 00:37:20,844 She's guilty of murder. 576 00:37:25,044 --> 00:37:28,524 You're certain of that, are you? My team are. And I trust them. 577 00:37:28,564 --> 00:37:32,004 Well, you should have warned me. How? How could I? 578 00:37:32,044 --> 00:37:34,884 Those were private moments between us. 579 00:37:36,844 --> 00:37:39,524 We managed to keep them a secret for this long. 580 00:37:40,324 --> 00:37:43,324 I remembered them fondly - until today. 581 00:37:44,924 --> 00:37:49,364 I can't let her walk free, Anthonia. And what if she's telling the truth? 582 00:37:49,404 --> 00:37:51,404 She isn't. 583 00:38:01,284 --> 00:38:06,764 My parents trusted him, so when he took me away for days at a time, they never questioned it. 584 00:38:06,804 --> 00:38:10,204 The first time, he drove me to a cottage in the middle of the countryside. 585 00:38:10,244 --> 00:38:13,564 And there he forced me to have sex with him. 586 00:38:15,844 --> 00:38:19,524 I let him because I wanted to please him. But it hurt. 587 00:38:20,844 --> 00:38:23,084 When I said that I'd tell someone, he'd laugh. 588 00:38:23,124 --> 00:38:27,404 He said no-one would believe a screw-up like me and I'd end up in the loony bin. 589 00:38:31,524 --> 00:38:34,324 And then he would touch me and tell me we were in love. 590 00:38:40,284 --> 00:38:42,284 After a few years... 591 00:38:43,444 --> 00:38:45,444 ..the sex felt normal. 592 00:38:47,124 --> 00:38:51,644 My behaviour was better in public, so I told him I wanted to go to college. 593 00:38:52,684 --> 00:38:56,164 And he went crazy. He drove me to a mental institution. 594 00:38:56,204 --> 00:38:58,524 He parked opposite, where I could see the gates, 595 00:38:58,564 --> 00:39:01,564 and he said he would have me committed if I tried to leave him. 596 00:39:01,604 --> 00:39:02,964 And then... 597 00:39:03,004 --> 00:39:06,404 he forced me to have sex with him right there, in the car. 598 00:39:06,444 --> 00:39:10,044 He said he was turned on by the idea that someone might see. 599 00:39:10,084 --> 00:39:14,764 Yeah. Oh, hello, Joe. It's me, yeah. Are you near a computer? 600 00:39:14,804 --> 00:39:16,884 I dropped out of school. 601 00:39:17,724 --> 00:39:20,684 My parents didn't seem to care. 602 00:39:20,724 --> 00:39:24,404 And then, not long after, he announced that my... 603 00:39:25,684 --> 00:39:27,764 ..therapy had been a success. 604 00:39:31,684 --> 00:39:34,444 For a moment I thought I was free. But... 605 00:39:34,484 --> 00:39:36,644 then he told me that we were getting married. 606 00:39:36,684 --> 00:39:38,884 Well, look in the other file. 607 00:39:38,924 --> 00:39:41,084 Yeah, keep looking. 608 00:39:43,964 --> 00:39:47,364 Hi. I need access to exhibit 17, the Crown versus Gardner case. 609 00:39:47,404 --> 00:39:50,444 Quick as you can, thank you. Yeah, sure. 610 00:39:50,484 --> 00:39:52,404 Really? 611 00:39:52,444 --> 00:39:54,444 That's great. Well done. 612 00:39:56,244 --> 00:40:00,084 'You looked at me and began to unbutton your blouse. 613 00:40:00,124 --> 00:40:03,124 We were parked right opposite the hospital. 614 00:40:03,164 --> 00:40:05,564 It was so blatant and forbidden.' 615 00:40:05,604 --> 00:40:07,404 Kate! 'We couldn't help ourselves.' 616 00:40:07,444 --> 00:40:10,484 Kate! I think I've found something. 617 00:40:12,844 --> 00:40:14,124 I've found Clare. 618 00:40:14,164 --> 00:40:18,124 I heard him talking on the tape, and... it was all the same, 619 00:40:18,164 --> 00:40:20,044 the same games, the same tricks... 620 00:40:22,524 --> 00:40:24,564 But now he was doing it to someone else. 621 00:40:25,684 --> 00:40:27,524 I don't remember walking to the office. 622 00:40:27,564 --> 00:40:29,684 I don't remember leaving the house. 623 00:40:29,724 --> 00:40:32,324 I'd seen the knife before in his desk, 624 00:40:32,364 --> 00:40:35,004 and he was lying on the sofa. 625 00:40:39,404 --> 00:40:41,764 And I stabbed him. 626 00:40:43,284 --> 00:40:45,324 No further questions, Your Honour. 627 00:40:48,964 --> 00:40:51,724 Why didn't you go to the police when you heard the tape? 628 00:40:51,764 --> 00:40:54,564 Clare would never speak against him, so nothing would happen. 629 00:40:54,604 --> 00:40:57,524 And why did you say that you loved him? 630 00:40:57,564 --> 00:41:00,044 I-I said what I was expected to say. 631 00:41:00,084 --> 00:41:03,604 Would it be fair to say that his actions were not threatening? 632 00:41:03,644 --> 00:41:05,604 Wasn't he trying to help you? 633 00:41:17,444 --> 00:41:18,684 Mr Thorne? 634 00:41:23,324 --> 00:41:25,844 Mr Thorne? Yes, yes. I just need... 635 00:41:33,084 --> 00:41:35,524 Yes. 636 00:41:38,924 --> 00:41:42,524 You mentioned that Dr Gardner drove you to a country cottage. 637 00:41:42,564 --> 00:41:44,284 Could you tell the court about this? 638 00:41:44,324 --> 00:41:48,364 I...I don't really remember. He took me to lots of places. 639 00:41:48,404 --> 00:41:51,804 But the first one. What do you remember about that? 640 00:41:51,844 --> 00:41:56,284 It was about an hour's drive from my parents. Very remote. 641 00:41:56,324 --> 00:41:59,884 There was a small town nearby, but otherwise we were completely isolated. 642 00:41:59,924 --> 00:42:01,884 And what was the name of that town? 643 00:42:03,844 --> 00:42:07,444 I...I can't remember. 644 00:42:07,484 --> 00:42:09,564 Your Honour, with your permission, 645 00:42:09,604 --> 00:42:13,124 may I play an excerpt from one of the tapes for the court? 646 00:42:26,964 --> 00:42:28,724 'And you laughed. 647 00:42:28,764 --> 00:42:32,244 You looked at me and began to unbutton your blouse. 648 00:42:32,284 --> 00:42:36,604 We were parked right opposite the hospital. 649 00:42:36,644 --> 00:42:39,164 It was so blatant and forbidden, 650 00:42:39,204 --> 00:42:42,924 but we couldn't help ourselves. 651 00:42:42,964 --> 00:42:44,684 I'd become part of your disease 652 00:42:44,724 --> 00:42:50,164 and I knew right then that... I had to be your doctor for life.' 653 00:42:51,164 --> 00:42:53,484 'We were parked right opposite the hospital.' 654 00:42:53,524 --> 00:42:57,644 You said you and he had sex right outside a mental institution. 655 00:42:57,684 --> 00:43:01,084 No! He's describing YOU, isn't he? 656 00:43:01,124 --> 00:43:02,204 No! 657 00:43:04,524 --> 00:43:06,324 What was the name of that town, Alison? 658 00:43:06,364 --> 00:43:08,404 I... I don't... I can't... 659 00:43:08,444 --> 00:43:12,444 The town was called Clare. It's the name written on all these tapes. 660 00:43:12,484 --> 00:43:15,164 I think - You thought he had betrayed you. 661 00:43:16,684 --> 00:43:18,524 But the tapes are actually a memoir. 662 00:43:18,564 --> 00:43:23,084 Dr Gardner named them after the town that you and he first went together. 663 00:43:23,124 --> 00:43:27,964 These tapes are a testament of his love for you. 664 00:43:28,004 --> 00:43:30,004 Isn't that right? 665 00:43:31,524 --> 00:43:33,524 There is no other girl. 666 00:43:34,044 --> 00:43:36,324 No betrayal. No repeated offence. 667 00:43:36,364 --> 00:43:38,684 No Clare. 668 00:43:38,724 --> 00:43:40,204 There was only you. 669 00:43:43,404 --> 00:43:45,764 Alison? 670 00:43:45,804 --> 00:43:47,804 Oh, Philip! 671 00:43:49,284 --> 00:43:52,284 Philip! He never raped you, did he? 672 00:43:52,324 --> 00:43:54,484 He fell in love with you, and you with him. 673 00:43:54,524 --> 00:43:59,324 But you were so scared that he was going to leave you, that you killed him. 674 00:44:01,084 --> 00:44:02,964 I am a rock in a sea of chaos. 675 00:44:03,004 --> 00:44:05,004 A rock in a sea of chaos.... 676 00:44:05,044 --> 00:44:07,044 Did he abuse you, Alison? 677 00:44:11,164 --> 00:44:13,884 Alison? 678 00:44:13,924 --> 00:44:15,924 No! 679 00:44:16,684 --> 00:44:18,684 No. He loved me! 680 00:44:20,204 --> 00:44:24,284 He promised he would save me, and he did. And I loved him! 681 00:44:28,204 --> 00:44:30,444 I loved him. What do I do now? 682 00:44:32,484 --> 00:44:34,484 What do I do? 683 00:44:37,044 --> 00:44:38,844 What do I do now? 684 00:44:50,004 --> 00:44:52,004 Time for a drink? 685 00:44:52,684 --> 00:44:55,364 You won. You too. Well spotted. 686 00:44:55,404 --> 00:44:57,404 It was more Ronnie than me. 687 00:44:58,364 --> 00:45:02,244 Look at us both trying not to take any credit. 688 00:45:02,284 --> 00:45:05,004 You were right. She was very convincing. 689 00:45:05,044 --> 00:45:07,724 The jury would have gone with her. We got lucky. 690 00:45:09,924 --> 00:45:11,924 Do you feel lucky? 691 00:45:14,949 --> 00:45:50,800